* * * * * *
hi-fi+ magazine for audiophiles, music listeners, vinyl collectors hi-fi+ magazine features highly informative and readable articles on all sorts of hi-fi and music *
* * HOME *
* *
Current issue contentWhere to get hi-fi+Our Reviewshi-fi+ back issuesContacting hi-fi+Business contact formsUseful links
On this page
Music Reviews from Issue 17
Whilst we offer contact numbers and links to our suppliers websites for your convenience hi-fi+ does not support or endorse any of the businesses involved.
Back to hi-fi+ welcome page | Back to Last Page | This issues contents
Next pop / jazz Reviews | Next classical / Audiophile Review | Music Review Index
 
Welcome>Music reviews >Issue 17 classical
   
   

Search the Music Review Database

   
Issue 17, the reviews
Classical Music    
 

Webern: Passacaglia; Five Movements for Strings; Six Pieces; Five Pieces; Symphony; Variations
Ulster Orchestra/Yuasa
Naxos 8.554841
Reviewed by SG
Anton Webern remains one of the most influential composers of the 20th Century, despite only crediting thirty-one of his works with opus numbers. While his early influences were clearly the leading romantic composers, following studies with Schoenberg, he gave priority to atonality and serial composition, and would later inspire the likes of Stravinsky, Boulez and Stockhausen. While Karajan's and Boulez's recordings with the Berlin Philharmonic on DG have the Berliner's famous tonal beauty, and may demonstrate more of the momentous turmoil that is the fundamental nature of Webern's compositions, this disc reveals an excellent performance and a very good recording, that still manages to reveal resounding climaxes. Takuo Yuasa's direction is splendid, with articulation and delicately considered minimalism presenting wonderfully anxious virtues. He guides the Ulster Orchestra to generate an abundance of detail and a considerable scale of expressiveness, while their playing is of a very high order, achieving great tonal poise. Highlight is the remarkable Funeral March from the fourth of the Six Pieces, where Yuasa generates the escalating intensity more vividly than any previously. With relatively few tempting recordings of Webern's work available, this CD is a welcome introduction, making it yet another highly recommended release from Naxos.

  sleeve image
Recording=9, Music=9CD format
       
 

Rimsky-Korsakov: Scheherazade
Borodin: Polovtsian dances
RPO, Beecham
EMI 5 66983-2
Reviewed by JMH
With his love of the unusual and exotic, Sir Thomas was in many ways the ideal interpreter for Scheherazade - one who revelled in its bright vulgar colours and unabashed sonic splendour. His 1958 LP of Rimsky's great orchestral showpiece was justly celebrated as one of the finest ever issued. And hearing it almost half a century later on CD the magic remains undimmed. Of course he had an outstanding orchestra at his disposal; listen to the way the strings shimmer and soar in the first movement, or the characterful individuality of the winds in the second. Some say Scheherazade is 'second rate' stuff. Maybe so. But heard in a performance like this, the music positively glows. Luckily, EMI's Kingsway Hall recording wears its years lightly, sounding vivid, clean, and well balanced, with low tape noise and excellent fine detail. The Polovstian Dances (complete with chorus) were taped a year or so earlier, but sound well -just a shade brighter and more forward than the main work. The performance is lusty, full-blooded, and very committed, with that curious Beecham mix of driving power and relaxed genial sensuality. The close of the work is sensational - the sort of thing to bring any audience to its feet stamping and cheering.

  sleeve image
Recording=6, Music=10CD format
       
 

Saariaho: Graal Theatre; Chateau de Lame; Amers
Kremer / Upshaw / Karttunen / BBC SO / Salonen
Sony SK 60817
Reviewed by SG
During the last decade, Kaija Saariaho's style of musical composition fundamentally changed. These are three of her major works and bridge this transformation, with Amers, from 1992, belonging to the earlier style that established her reputation. This work is composed for cello (Anssi Karttunen), ensemble and electronics, and consists of sounds dancing in fields of textures, coloured by ever altering conformity. The Graal Theatre was the first major work to concentrate on more uniform melodies, exhibiting stronger patterns of rhythm. It is a powerful violin concerto, in two remarkable movements, with the challenging solo part written specifically for Gidon Kremer. His instrument leads the orchestra through diverse musical settings until they finally establish themselves in conflict with each other. Chateau de L'ame is a set of ecstatically absorbing pieces for soprano (Dawn Upshaw), choir and orchestra, set to Indian and Egyptian texts of love. The supporting musicians make them wonderfully expressive pieces by providing each with contradictory acoustical characteristics. The engineering is very good, especially in the two works recorded in Finland, from where there comes a more open and detailed sound. With very good performances by all, this is an excellent introduction to Saariaho's imaginative writing.

  sleeve image
Recording=9, Music=8CD format
       
 

Janacek: A Recollection
Schiff
ECM (New Series 1736) 461 660-2
Reviewed by SG
Andras Schiff is a distinctly unassuming, yet intelligent, pianist who lets the elegance of his playing and the expressions in the composition do the talking. This was clearly evident in his recent "Chopin and his idols" recitals at the Wigmore Hall, and is also apparent here, with Schiff exhibiting a wonderful finesse and fluidity. This approach matches the expression and intensity of Janacek's poignant writing perfectly, with pianist and composer fused into one delightfully persuasive entity. Whether it is the furtive, sonata-like In the Mist, the tragic masterpiece of Sonata IX 1905, which commemorates a Czech worker bayoneted by Habsburg soldiers on the date in the title, the superbly introspective An Overgrown Path or the reflective A Recollection, it is the subtlety of phrasing, combined with tense breaks in tempo, that make this performance so beautifully satisfying. Schiff shows a great understanding for the polyphonic aspects of these works, as well as a sense to their true proportion, and so brings out the elegance and sophistication that is present throughout. Combined with a wonderfully resonant recording, Schiffs benchmark performance of some of Janacek's intensely intimate, yet far too rare, keyboard miniatures can simply be described as exquisite.

  sleeve image
Recording=9, Music=10CD format
       
 

Boccherini: String Quartets, Op. 32, Nos. 3-6
Quartetto Borciani
Naxos 8.555043
Reviewed by SG
Following the Borciani s first disc of Luigi Boccherini's String Quartets (Naxos 8.555042) comes this even more enchanting disc. While his chamber music may not be as well known as that of either Haydn or Mozart's, due to it not exhibiting the resolute aspirations of his two more celebrated contemporaries, Boccherini's does incorporate some delightfully genial writing, and splendidly distinct structures, as in the Allegro bizzarro, at the opening of the Quartet in C major, Op. 32, No. 4. The Quartetto Borciani play the four works here with obvious enthusiasm, revealing a certain amount of passion and exhilaration when the music warrants it, with the finale of the Quartet in G minor, Op. 32, No. 5 - Capriccio ad libitum -revealing both composer and players at their most lively. They characterise each distinct movement magnificently, and manage to urge even the more serene pieces forward with lively playing and wonderfully constant tempos, giving the music some additional support. The Quartet also possesses a wonderful Italianate character that is decidedly suggestive of their predecessors, the wonderful Quartetto Italiano. Naxos' sonics are excellent with natural tones and a nice amount of reverberation assisting the performance, making this a highly enjoyable recording.

  sleeve image
Recording=9, Music=9CD format
       
 

J.S.Bach: Keyboard concertos 1, 2, and 4
Murray Perahia (piano), ASMF, Marriner
Sony SK 89245
Reviewed by JMH
Playing baroque music on modern instruments seems to be coming back into fashion again. And why not? After decades of purist performances using slimmed-down authentic forces, it's good once in a while to hear the music of Bach and Handel played with the warmth and fullness of tone one gets from contemporary instruments. Not that the present performances sound excessively lush or rich. Agreed, the sound picture is darker and fuller than it would be with authentic baroque forces. But fast tempi and crisp articulation ensure that the sound remains clean and transparent. The soloist is balanced quite closely, but the clarity of the recording ensures plenty of orchestral detail. Wisely, I think, Perahia and Marriner dispense with harpsichord continuo. Historically it might not be correct, but (to my ears at least) it sounds right not to have it. Instead, a discreetly balanced Theorbo is employed, and its softer tone quality compliments the rounder sound of a modern Concert Grand. Marriner's complete EMI set of these concertos from the '80s with pianist Andrei Gavrilov included a harpsichord, and it was strange to hear it tinkling away in the background with a modern Klavier playing the solo part. Sony's recording is smooth, clean, and very refined, with excellent clarity and believable balances.

  sleeve image
Recording=8, Music=8CD format
       
Audiophile Recordings    
 

Dave's True Story - Sex Without Bodies
Cheskey JD164
Reviewed by RP
Dave's True Story is vocalist, Kelly Flint, who can certainly hold a tune, and guitarist, David Cantor, who can't. However, as author of twelve of the thirteen songs here, his contribution should never be under estimated. Soft focus, stylised jazzy melodies for upright bass, vibes, tenor, and baritone sax, clothe intriguing lyrical constructs. There's a laconic title-track, dealing with phone sex, or, 'Ned's Big Dutch Wife', who leads a double life running a brothel. The quirky, 'I'll Never Read Trollope Again', and 'Spasm', with its' raw instinctive sexual advocacy, Cantor throws together some fascinating and unexpected images. Witticisms aplenty, too, in the shape of "The men with their inner lives / As grim and as grainy as super B / There's no manner of appetite / That Ned's big Dutch wife won't sate", are diva-delivered in a timeless and quite beautiful fashion. An incongruous scenario? Well, almost, as, for a second, you're seduced by Flint's hypnotic cadences and, in the next moment, slapped back to consciousness through Cantor's unconventional language, proving the attractiveness of opposites. An unlikely church setting of St. Peters Episcopal, New York enshrines these performances with a resonant, highly revealing and pristine acoustic.
Supplier: Vivante - www.vivante.co.uk (44)(0)1293-822186

  sleeve image
Recording=9, Music=7CD formatSuppied by Vivante, click to go buy it
       
 

Love - Forever Changes
Sundazed LP5102
Reviewed by RP
When folk label, Elektra moved into the realms of progressive rock their first signing was an innovative band familiar to the LA club circuit - Love. The second group to put pen to paper was none other than the Doors! Forever Changes (Love's third album, released in 1967) was and is a sensational soft-focus psychedelic record that no serious collection should be without. At it's centre lies the wayward genius of Bryan Maclean and Arthur Lee, a partnership which did not survive the mercurial brilliance of an album that switches back and forth between those darkly powerful images buried within literally-titled songs like 'A House Is Not A Motel' (with it's ominous echoes of South East Asia) and the comforting melodies offered up in the lovely, 'Andmoreagain: When you are a black man fronting an ostensibly white rock band in "civil rights era" America, I suppose you will breath, eat, sleep and awake smelling the contradictions. Duality permeates Lee's imagination - revealing itself thematically and structurally through those expansive and lush sounding arrangements. The tactical application of keyboard and electric guitar overdubs bakes in these sentiments. Each will have his or her favourite moment, and mine will always be the breezy, over-optimistic evocation, 'Between Clarke And Hilldale'. Outstanding music.
Supplier: The Cherished Record Company - www.cherished-record-company.co.uk (44)(0)1579 363603

  sleeve image
Recording=5, Music=10180g VinylSuppied by Cherished Record Company click to go buy it
       
 

John Lee Hooker - It Serve You Right To Suffer
Speakers Corner/impulse AS-9103
Reviewed by RG
There will always be a market for John Lee Hooker discs, so synonymous is his name with the blues. So much so that it's easy to assume a degree of cynicism as regards the consistent flow of re-issues. However, that would be misplaced in this instance. Speaker's Corner have unearthed a real gem in this 1965 recording, featuring seven Hooker originals and the Berry Gordy penned 'Money'. Taped in a single day, there's a real sense of performance here, critical to great blues and absent from far too many recordings, including many of those on 'audiophile' labels. This is the real thing, with Hookers gritty vocals the perfect counterpoint to his spare, incisive guitar. Fronting a four piece, things never get too cluttered, tempos never lag as the band fall perfectly into his footsteps. Having said that, the highest point here is the down-beat, virtually unaccompanied 'Country Boy'. Even with things slowed right down, Hooker's sense of pace and his metronomic command of rhythm, never desert him. His tempo is emphatic, towering, driving power into his words. It's why his blues are so enduring, and why, at the end of the day, he remains the man.

  sleeve image
Recording=7, Music=9180g Vinyl
       
 

Ravel: Complete Orchestral Works
Cluytens / PCO / Rene Duclos Choir
Testament EMI SAX 2476-9
Reviewed by RP
This is an immensely satisfying and genuinely delightful compendium which, across these four open-sounding LPs, vividly traces those remarkable developments in personality, style and technique that define the evolving art of a master orchestrator. So effectively so, in fact, that we have largely forgotten that these sparkling concert hall favourites in a delicate 'Le Tombeau', languorous 'Alborada' and deliciously sentimental 'Pavane pour une infante defunte', were originally scored for piano only. Meanwhile, an exhilarating Spanish-influenced 'Rapsodie Espagnole' with it's pleasing rubato and subtle tonal shifts, together with these piquant, bitter-sweet textures in a hedonistic 'Valse Nobles' are beautifully realised. As is a magnificent evocation of ancient Greece for 'Daphnis et Chloe'. Conductor and orchestra revel in such sensual music. Splendid all-round musicianship, then, especially throughout the many flute solos and harp passages which, consequently, stand out with startling clarity. The two flutes heard at the opening of 'Ma Mere L'oye' actually light up what is usually considered to be a remote and ostensibly cool composition. Thus placing a notably different emphasis on proceedings. Rarer, impressionistic pieces like 'Une barque' and that earlier and quite weighty 'Menuet antique' from 1894 are important inclusions. The former is a bobby-dazzler in the 'Alborada' vein. Both being drawn from the piano suite, 'Miroirs', while the 'Menuet, charts Ravels emergence from under Chabrier's shadow. They definitely have their place as, I suppose, does that hypnotically swirling 'Bolero' which I could personally live another lifetime without. Sonically, these Testament remasters major on warmth and, reputedly, deliver a far greater degree of transparency than was to be found on the originals. The cut on to lacquer at EMI's Abbey Road Studios and the 1809m pressing at their Hayes plant are exceptional, with residual tape hiss kept to a minimum. Moreover, this all adds to the success of a recording where instruments like those prominent flutes or, elsewhere, the woodwind for 'Daphnis' and horns of the 'Pavane', impose themselves without becoming uncomfortably strident. A nice sense of balance is struck here and yet the precise detail, shape and form of individual images is still there to be heard. In 'Daphnis' this solidity and assurance extends to a flawless reproduction of the chorus. Proving, overall, that we should role back the decades in an unprejudiced way and think of these recut performances as rightly being forty years young.
Supplier: The Cherished Record Company - www.cherished-record-company.co.uk (44)(0)1579 363603

  sleeve image
Recording=8, Music=9180g (Multi) VinylAvailability 1Suppied by Cherished Record Company click to go buy it
       
 

Image Hi-Fi
Vinyl Essentials - The Ultimate Pickup Test Record
Image Hi-Fi LP003
Reviewed by RG
A decent test record is indispensable when it comes to optimising LP replay systems. All the measurements and calculations in the world are no substitute for practical testing of what is after-all a mechanical process. Tools, like decent alien keys and a nice large spirit level keep things tight and level and their necessity is easily understood. Just consider this as another tool. As well as the standard channel and phase checks (essential to check correct cartridge and tonearm wiring) you also get the important stuff. That means a cross-talk test, tone arm resonance test and tracking test. Of these, the last two are the really critical ones. The instructions are clear and concise (and in English as well as the native German), ensuring that you achieve the correct results. The resonance test in particular is essential if you want to achieve optimum damping performance from a tonearm with a fluid damping option, such as the various SMEs. What's even more interesting is the fact that Image provide three identical tracking tests, so that rapidly repeated use of the high level tracks won't cause premature wear (to the disc or your nerves as you try to track a damaged signal). The heavy pressing is also flat, which helps, unlike some of the competition. Highly recommended.
Supplier: Vivante - www.vivante.co.uk (44)(0)1293-822186

 

sleeve image
Recording=10, Music=not applicable180g VinylSuppied by Vivante, click to go buy it

       

  Top | Last page | Music Review Index | Technical Review Index | Back Issues Index | Show Reviews | Subscribe | Latest Issue | News | Letters
| Home page | Site Map |
 
  Music Reviews by Issue | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 | 32 | 33 | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | 38 | 39 | 40 | 41 | 42 | 43 | 44 | 45 | 46 | 47 | 48 | 49 | 50 | 51 | 52 | 53 | 54 | 55 | 56 | 57 | 58 | 59 | 60 |