* * * * * *
hi-fi+ magazine for audiophiles, music listeners, vinyl collectors hi-fi+ magazine features highly informative and readable articles on all sorts of hi-fi and music *
* * HOME *
* *
Current issue contentWhere to get hi-fi+Our Reviewshi-fi+ back issuesContacting hi-fi+Business contact formsUseful links
 

On this page
Music Reviews from Issue 48

Whilst we offer contact numbers and links to our suppliers websites for your convenience hi-fi+ does not support or endorse any of the businesses involved.
Back to hi-fi+ welcome page | Back to Last Page | This issues contents
Next pop / jazz Reviews | Next classical / Audiophile Review | Music Review Index

 
   
   

Search the Music Review Database

   

Classical Music

   
 

Fiddler Tam: The Music of Thomas Erskine
David McGuinness, Concerto Caledonia
Linn Records CKD 240
Reviewed by RP
A son of Scotland and contemporary of Haydn, Thomas Erskine (the 6th Earl of Kellie) was an eminent violinist and prolific composer. His cavalier approach to the Baroque resulted in an often euphoric, exceptionally lovely, highly enjoyable and varied body of work that combines lyricism and wit with some marvellous harmonies. Death Is Now My Only Treasure and The Lover’s Message featuring the soprano Mhairi Lawson drip with Masonic symbolism and metaphysical rakishness.
His “message” is a coy yet charmingly insincere one - playing the “dying for love” card for all it’s worth in the time honoured pursuit of sexual congress. David McGuiness’ keyboard skills on the harpsichord and his sympathetic direction of the Concerto Caledonia players both here and for other pieces like the lively The Maid Of The Mill Overture, the vivid and emotionally sophisticated Quartet in A and through the courtly elegance found in the Trio Sonata No.5 in E effortlessly guides us amongst the trysts, expressive exchanges and poetic conceits. Performed on period instruments, this atmospheric recording taped in the Crichton Collegiate church, Midlothian and at St. Judes on the Hill in London has persuasive warmth, delicacy and refinement about it that adds to an amiable and occasionally impassioned gesture or two buried within this agreeable music.

  sleeve image
Recording=8, Music=8Hybrid SACD HD format
       
 

Shostakovitch: Piano Works
Vladimir Ashkenazy, Piano
Decca 470 649-2
Reviewed by RP
A great piano recording and fine performance full of robust firmly located images, which also shows us just how much delicacy this format possesses.
It recreates each and every subtle dynamic shift or explosive exclamation delivered by the impeccable and dexterous hands of Vladimir Ashkenazy in this wonderfully coherent and consistent approach. He gives a virtuoso display throughout, right from an opening Piano Sonata No.2 whose sparse thematic
material is woven around this most traditional of forms to those miniatures like the Nocturne from The Limpid Stream or Lyric Waltz originally found in Dances of the Dolls. Then there’s those Aphorisms Op.13: ten youthful, short, revolutionary pieces, ever so pithy in nature, which are loosely associated with dance forms. “Succinct” is the watchword both here and in the quite charming rendition of his Five Preludes and that capricious and very popular work, the Three Fantastic Dances. Shostakovich piano compositions are not always comfortable or easily accessible but they have undeniable character and Ashkenazy (who is an elegant master of shape, tonality and drama) perhaps more than any of his esteemed peers, cuts to the heart of each structure to expose the underlying intent.

  sleeve image
Recording=9, Music=8Hybrid SACD format
       
 

Rachmaninov: Piano Concerto No.2 & Rhapsody On A Theme Of Paganini
Lang Lang, piano, Valery Gergiev,
Marinsky Theatre Orchestra
DGG 00289 477 5499
Reviewed by RP
The Second Piano Concerto is one of my favourites because of those broadly romantic moods so tinged with suffering and its grand sweeping melodies of tremendous beauty. Chinese born pianist Lang Lang taps into the expressive heart of this music through a precise, fluent and eminently likeable reading that
balances differing demands within a score that calls both for considered reflection and vitality.
He adopts safe speeds (unlike Richter’s controversial and famously slow, yet highly successful reading of the first movement coupled to a breakneck tempo for the allegro found in his early 1960s recording for this label) but does not overstate a languid and relaxed side heard in the slower sections of this concerto. For the Rhapsody his elasticity and flair conveys the true sense of impetus, excitement and virtuosity underpinning this music. Conductor, orchestra and soloist really gel in these performances and the instrumental balance has been astutely engineered to reveal that rich, sonorous and firmly focused piano timbre as well as the wider enveloping warmth conveyed by the Marinsky Theatre players. Overall, this is an excellent recording of a powerful and persuasive rendition possessing considerable emotional depth.

 

sleeve image
Recording=10, Music=9SACD format

       
 

Handel: Six Violin Sonatas
Bach: Partita No.2
Alfredo Campoli, violin; George Malcolm, harpsichord
Testament SBT 1358
Reviewed by RP
The Partita No.2 with its renowned Chaconne dates from 1948 and is the only unaccompanied Bach recording made by Campoli, so in one respect it is a valuable musical document.
However this is a performance that I am not completely comfortable with, mainly due to a rather seesawing nature to the chords and an understated almost modest approach to such a virtuoso piece. However, the Six Violin Sonatas ascribed to Handel have more purposeful, strongly melodic and rhythmic qualities. Campoli’s playing here, and that of his eminent accompanist, George Malcolm, conveys the stately magnificence of this score with great assurance. Testament’s transfer improves upon an early 1950s Decca LP. The instrumental balance is superior, with the violin better focused, revealing the tonal richness and warmth of the Campoli technique. True, there are a few lapses of phrasing in the slower movements but these can be overlooked because of the obvious rapport that these musicians had for chamber works of this kind. It certainly illuminates how their approach fifty years ago differed from that of today’s luminaries of bow and board.

 

sleeve image
Recording=6, Music=7CD format

       
 

Hugo Alfvén: Symphony No. 4, ‘From The Outermost Skerries’
Iceland Symphony Orchestra;
Niklas Willén, cond.
Naxos 8.557284
Reviewed by RP
A soft murmur, like water silently flowing its way, vents in an eruptive demonstration of the sheer force of the ocean. Suddenly silence, a solo violin creates the atmosphere of moonlight shining on dark water. “The action takes place in the Skerries, where sea rages among the rocks...” Seldom have pictures of nature been painted in music with such a vividness and attention to detail to make a program unnecessary! One wonders whether he was also a talented water colourist – he uses the orchestra almost as if he’s using paint! God moves in mysterious ways, but one also wonders why Hugo Alfvén hasn’t been paid as much attention as he deserves.
Alfvén, like George Enesco, transformed the love of his country into music. Inspired by the rich and colourful traditional and folk music, his compositions are deeply seated on the sound of the symphonic poems of Smetana and others from the 19th century. Perhaps this retrospective focus and lack of obvious innovation explains his failure to reach a public outside Sweden. His use of human voices as musical instruments is really touching, and fits perfectly. The male and female voices bear witness to a love story – but the star role is reserved for nature, and that provides more than enough fuel for great emotion and drama, for sure!

 

sleeve image
Recording=8, Music=8CD format

       
 

Respighi: Ancient Dances And Airs For Lute Suites 1,2 & 3
Antal Dorati conducting the Philharmonia Hungarica
Mercury 470 637-2 MSA
Reviewed by RP
Some forty-five years after they were originally recorded these brilliant and exceptionally sensitive performances by Dorati’s countrymen remain the finest available. Respighi’s taxing Twentieth Century string orchestration of Renaissance and Baroque dance music with its three or four part chords and exposed high notes are eloquently delivered through an enviable degree of delicacy, elegance and liveliness. Exquisite, atmospheric and beautifully sculpted scenes effortlessly unfold before us. Played out with such sublime virtuosity, especially in the harpsichord part, that this version demands a place in every collection. The choice of format though will provoke a much more intense debate. I have American, British and French LPs and the standard CD release to choose from as points of reference. The CD layer is the same as before, but the SACD’s layer’s position within this hierarchy is an interesting one. It does not replace my U.S. FR1/FR3 pressing SR 90199 at the top of the pile (RSF probably owns an even better cut) but does possess sufficient clarity, detail and warmth to take second spot. What it lacks is that musical snap and sheer presence, naturalness and instrumental lustre heard from the LP. However, at £11.99 the SACD is realistically priced; a pristine vintage vinyl copy will set you back much more.

 

sleeve image
Recording=8, Music=10Hybrid SACD format

 
   

Audiophile Recordings

   
 

Mel Tormé with The Marty Paich Orchestra - Swing Schubert Alley
Speakers Corner Records
Reviewed by DDD
Tormé’s recording career as a jazz vocalist spanned half of the twentieth century. He recorded extensively for Bethlehem in the 1950s, Verve in the 1960s and Concord Jazz during the last two decades of the century. This 1960 Norman Granz production, (originally released as Verve MG VS-6146) teams Tormé with the Marty Paich Orchestra capturing a swinging session with these musicians at the top of their game. The orchestra of west coast all-stars includes Art Pepper, Frank Rosolino, Red Callender and Bill Perkins. Like Paich’s better known, and extremely collectible LPs on Warner Bros. Records from the late 1950s, this is west coast jazz at its finest. Tormé performs a selection of show tune chestnuts (from the likes of Cole Porter, Leonard Bernstein and Oscar Hammerstein) chosen for their jazz potential. Torme’ voice during this period is a fascinating blend of Tony Bennett and Wayne Newton. I had not listened to this record in many years, and within seconds of dropping stylus on vinyl, my attention was transfixed and I was scribbling notes about how this record knocked my socks off.
I cannot think of another Tormé album I prefer; it catches him at the peak of his vocal powers, in stunning sound. Speakers Corner has done another great job in mastering this well recorded session.
Don’t miss this under-appreciated treasure.

  sleeve image
Recording=9, Music=9180g Vinyl
       
 

Tchaikosky: Violin Concerto in D, Piano Concerto No. 1
Tetzlaff; Lugansky.
Nagano, Russian N.O.
Pentatone Classics PTC 5186 022
Reviewed by RSF
This is one excellent disc! While I’m sure you’ve already got your favourite recordings of these two Tchaikovsky concertos, I think you owe it to yourself to add this one to your collection. Prior to hearing the violin concerto, I was not familiar with Tetzlaff’s recordings. This German violinist certainly delivers the goods. There is nothing romantic about his playing and he delivers a precise reading that follows the music’s cohesive construction. But as good as Tetzlaff is with his violin, so too is Lugansky with the piano. I think he is currently one of the top pianists on the classical circuit. He’s very well represented in the recorded catalogues and has been recording since he was thirteen! While he is well known for his Rachmaninov (and he has performed a fabulous Chopin Etudes disc for Erato), I find his Tchaikovsky mesmerizing. His pace is rapid but not overbearing, insightful but still youthful, and his technique is exciting and gripping. As is the case with all Pentatone Classics, the CD layer is an exceptionally down-conversion of the DSD layers.
While this is not a new release it was new to me and I hope it will find a home with you. Not to be missed!
Supplier: www.pentatonemusic.com

  sleeve image
Recording=9, Music=10Hybrid SACD Multichannel formatSupplied by Pentatone Music
       
 

Rosemary Clooney and Duke Ellington - Blue Rose
Pure Pleasure Records
Reviewed by DDD
Like Mel Tormé, Rosemary Clooney spent her golden years recording for Concord Jazz. This recording, originally released as Columbia CL 872, may be the jewel of her discography. George Clooney’s aunt Rosemary puts her stamp on eleven Ellington/Strayhorn tunes backed by the Ellington band. During her early recording years, most of Clooney’s output was more pop oriented but she established her jazz credentials with this album, becoming one of Concord Records’ jazz stalwarts by the ‘8o’s. She turns in excellent renditions of several songs, especially ‘It Don’t Mean A Thing’ and ‘Mood Indigo’, but some of her work may seem a little tame in comparison to the top echelon of jazz vocalists from the golden era.
Or maybe it’s just that I can’t get the picture of Clooney’s role in White Christmas out of my mind when listening to her sing. Still, she puts almost any female jazz vocalist on the scene today to shame. The mono recording, like other Ellington Columbia recordings of the day, is as well done as anything that was being recorded at the time.
Even though Clooney’s vocals were overdubbed, it does not detract from an extremely fine recording.
Sit back with this splendid sounding record and wonder why nobody does it this way anymore. Kudos to Pure Pleasure for another winner.

  sleeve image
Recording=9, Music=8180g Vinyl
       
 

Ludwig Van Beethoven: Quatuors à cordes no.7, 8 & 9; "Razumovsky" op.59 no.1, 2 & 3.
The Tokyo String Quartet.
Harmonia Mundi HM807423/4
Reviewed by RSF
The Tokyo String Quartet has captivated audiences and critics alike since it was founded more than 30 years ago. It is comprised of violist Kazuhide Isomura, a founding member of the group; second violinist Kikuei Ikeda, who joined the ensemble in 1974; cellist Clive Greensmith, the former Principal Cellist of London's Royal Philharmonic Orchestra, who joined in 1999; and first violinist Martin Beaver, who joined the ensemble in 2002.
A new recording for Harmonia Mundi and a celebration of the quartet’s new configuration, we are treated to an exceptionally skilful performance of Beethoven’s quartets. With the revolutionary quartets of Opus 59, Beethoven left behind the classical confines of the genre and gave it a truly symphonic dimension. Count Andreas Kirillovich Razumovsky, the Russian ambassador in Vienna commissioned these works in 1806 and they were completed by Beethoven in six short months. The masterful playing here provides the perfect balance between technical control and emotional freedom. Harmonia Mundi has given us spectacular sound and the Tokyo gives us approximately 108 minutes of sheer excitement and beauty. These readings are exceptionally polished and are the first offering in a new set of Beethoven quartets by this fabulous group of players.
Supplier: www.harmoniamundi.com

  sleeve image
Recording=10, Music=10Hybrid SACD Multichannel formatSuppied by  Harmonia Mundi
       
 

Gerry Mulligan meets Ben Webster
Speakers Corner Records
Reviewed by DDD
This LP combines the sound of Ben Webster, the tenor saxophone’s most luscious sounding proponent, with Mulligan’s equally mellow baritone sax to give us the equivalent of double-double chocolate cake. It’s a true orgy of sound. The session was recorded in 1959, and in addition to Webster and Mulligan it features the classic west coast rhythm section of Jimmy Rowles on piano, Mel Lewis on drums and Leroy Vinnegar on bass. The LP mixes a number of slow ballads and up-tempo swinging numbers. Most are Gerry Mulligan compositions, and they are all perfectly suited to bring out the vibrato-laden sound of both soloists. The record was originally released as Verve MG VS-6104 with a photo cover of the two horn players, different from the art cover used on the mono release (MG V8343). This music is available on a CD in its original form and as a “complete” two CD package, including alternate takes. This stereo re-issue gives up nothing
to the mono version, with the soloists occupying their own space, rather than being each stuck left and right in their respective speakers. Any way you get this music, it is a desert island disc. Speakers Corner has done an exemplary job of remastering this well recorded session, in rich sound unrivaled by any CD. It deserves my highest recommendation.

  sleeve image
Recording=10, Music=10180g Vinyl
       
 

Sergei Rachmaninov: Piano Works
Yevgeny Sudbin
Bis 1518
Reviewed by RSF
Released in November of 2005, Sudbin’s second disc for Bis is a tour de force. The engineers have done a remarkable job in capturing the incredible sound and power of his Steinway Grand ‘D’. From the first moments of the Chopin Op. 22, you will be captured by the exquisite playing of this young master. I’ve only listened to this disc in stereo and whilst the CD layer is quite remarkable, I can only imagine what this will sound like on a full blown multi-channel configuration. After last year’s outing at the Northern Sound & Vision show in Manchester it’s not hard to imagine how much better a piano sounds in Multi-Channel surround than in stereo.
This is playing of the highest order. For someone who is only 26, it’s really quite amazing the vivid skills Sudbin brings to his piano. This is as exciting a piano disc of Rachmaninov works as I’ve ever heard. The performances are colourful, passionate and offer a deep sense of understanding you rarely hear from someone who’s as young as Sudbin. I am looking forward to more from this grand pianist.
He’ll have you sitting on the edge of your chair, holding on for dear life. Outstanding in every sense of the word!
Supplier: www.bis.se

  sleeve image
Recording=10, Music=10Hybrid SACD Multichannel formatSupplied by BIS
 
   
  Top | Last page | Music Review Index | Technical Review Index | Back Issues Index | Show Reviews | Subscribe | Latest Issue | News | Letters
| Home page | Site Map |
 
  Music Reviews by Issue | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 | 32 | 33 | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | 38 | 39 | 40 | 41 | 42 | 43 | 44 | 45 | 46 | 47 | 48 | 49 | 50 | 51 | 52 | 53 | 54 | 55 | 56 | 57 | 58 | 59 | 60 |