* * * * * *
hi-fi+ magazine for audiophiles, music listeners, vinyl collectors hi-fi+ magazine features highly informative and readable articles on all sorts of hi-fi and music *
* * HOME *
* *
Current issue contentWhere to get hi-fi+Our Reviewshi-fi+ back issuesContacting hi-fi+Business contact formsUseful links
 

On this page
Music Reviews from Issue 50

Whilst we offer contact numbers and links to our suppliers websites for your convenience hi-fi+ does not support or endorse any of the businesses involved.
Back to hi-fi+ welcome page | Back to Last Page | This issues contents
Next pop / jazz Reviews | Next classical / Audiophile Review | Music Review Index

 
   
   

Search the Music Review Database

   

Classical Music

   
 

Frédéric Chopin: 26 Préludes
Robert Schumann: Papillons, Op. 2.
Claudio Arrau, piano.
PentaTone Classics PTC 5186 165
Reviewed by RSF
PentaTone Classics, along with the engineering know how of Polyhymnia International BV, continues their tradition of mining musical masterpieces from the 1970’s quadraphonic catalogue of Philips Classics. With over 60 discs in the PentaTone catalogue to date that should be explored by all music lovers, these ‘classic’ performances are given first-rate sound you’d never know wasn’t from pure digital sources. The performances of Chopin and Schumann played by the great Chilean pianist Claudio Arrau, offer the music lover insightful, accurate readings of these important compositions. Arrau was one of the last century’s legendary masters of the piano and his skills are clearly heard in these entrancing performances. His personal repertoire was vast, from Beethoven through Schoenberg. His Liszt is legendary. Born in 1903, he spanned the Century, only dying in 1991. Listening to these two ‘old friends’ is a reminder of how great he truly was. I hope to see more Arrau performances re-issued in the future; the sound is truly exceptional. I really enjoyed listening to the CD layer, but have to admit that the real beauty is realized in multi-channel.
This is wonderful music, easily accessible and highly prized. Not to be missed.
Supplier: www.pentatonemusic.com

  sleeve image
Recording=7, Music=9Hybrid SACD Multichannel formatSupplied by Pentatone Music
       
 

Mozart: Chamber Music for Winds and Strings
Boston Symphony Chamber Players
BSO Classics 0601
Reviewed by RSF
I’ve always been a fan of the BSCP and was delighted to hear (and hear about) this all Mozart program which includes K581, the Clarinet Quintet, K407, the Horn Quintet as well as the Oboe and the Flute Quartets, K370 and K298 respectively.
While the actual members of the ensemble have changed over the years – they were first formed in 1964 under the tenure of Erich Leinsdorf – the quality of the playing by these principal members of the Boston Symphony Orchestra has remained of the highest calibre. This is an immensely enjoyable outing that contains cohesive, yet spontaneous performances. The sound quality is outstanding and the disc timing is generous at 76+ minutes.
There are not many comparable discs that offer performances of this standard and certainly nothing in the DSD market comes close. The CD layer is most likely a down-conversion, with a rich, not too reverberant acoustic. I have a particular fondness for the Clarinet and Horn Quintets and was extremely impressed with the playing of the principals involved, William R. Hudgins, clarinet and James Sommerville, horn. This is Mozart offered up with fashionable performances, exceptional sound and at a moderate price. Highly recommended and not to be missed.
Supplier: www.bso.org

  sleeve image
Recording=9, Music=9Hybrid SACD Multichannel formatSupplied by Boston Symphony Orchestra
       
 

Biber, Bach, Vivaldi: Icons Of Music – Violin Sonatas
Marco Fornaciari, Ernesto Merlini, Leonardo Colonna
fonè Signoricci cd 004
Reviewed by AKB
Italian violinist Marco Fornaciari performs violin sonatas by Biber, Bach and Vivaldi, and I am totally impressed. The sound of these original instruments – not as resonant as modern ones – fits perfectly with the church acoustic, not overloading it but sounding detailed and full of complex resolution.
The Austrian composer Biber is almost forgotten today, but he created wonderful sonatas for violin and basso continuo. Like Vivaldi, he was influenced by non-musical impressions – for his Sonatas of the Holy Rosary, it was scenes from the bible and the life of the Virgin Mary.
The original instruments demand their own technique, yet the sonatas sound surprisingly modern. I am often dissatisfied by recordings with historic instruments – in my opinion, they have become more about attitude than authenticity. They tend to be too dogmatic, sometimes too forced, sometimes too artificial. But sometimes, you hear a record that sounds so convincing it forces you to change your mind. Icons Of Music is just such a recording!

 

sleeve image
Recording=9, Music=10CD format

 
   

Audiophile Recordings

   
 

Plas Johnson - Positively
Pure Audiophile PA-005
Reviewed by DDD
Plas Johnson is not exactly a household name, but anyone who has watched the Peter Sellers’ movie Pink Panther will recall Johnson’s bluesy sound from the famous theme song. This is a re-issue of one of Johnson’s best Concord albums, made as an aside to backing any number of better known artists. He is accompanied here by the Concord house band, consisting of Ray Brown, Herb Ellis and Jake Hanna in this sextet outing. This is the kind of music you expect to hear on a Concord release – traditional, swinging and well recorded. If not the most challenging jazz, what it does, it does very, very well. The record swings, and reminds me of many great concerts I’ve enjoyed at the Concord Pavilion produced by Carl Jefferson, founder of the Concord label. Concord is well known for its excellent engineering, most often by Phil Edwards, and this is no exception, yet this deluxe vinyl set lifts the excellent sound a few notches. Stan Ricker’s half-speed mastering is largely responsible for that, along with spreading the grooves out over two heavy discs, pressed on heavy vinyl at RTI. Pure Pleasure also scores with wonderful packaging.
Except for the Japanese Venus Records releases, no record company today comes close to the quality of record sleeves provided by Pure Audiophile.
Kudos to Dennis Cassidy and his team!

  sleeve image
Recording=9, Music=7180g (Double) Vinyl
       
 

Diabolus in Musica: Accardo interprets Paganini
Charles Dutoit cond. LPO. Salvatore Accardo, violin.
Clearaudio/Deutsche Grammophon 477 6492
Reviewed by RSF
This one had me puzzled, but only for a little while. Although I see references to CD compilations in the liner notes, what is released here was originally recorded by DGG at various venues in the late 1970’s. I wasn’t familiar with Accardo’s work for the label during this period, but I can tell you that what I hear on this Clearaudio release gives me great food for musical thought. Paganini, the fire and brimstone composer (as well as, according to reports of the day, one of the greatest violinists who’s ever lived), is captured eloquently on this re-issue. While I did find the acoustic occasionally too reverberant for my taste, Accardo’s playing is thrilling and exceptionally vivid. He’s recorded perfectly by the engineers who not only deliver great dynamics, but also offer us the delicacy of a wonderful pianissimo in the form of a delicate triangle positioned properly in the orchestral venue. Each selection is a treat and I truly hope Clearaudio gets more
of this on vinyl. Very impressive and I think ‘a must own’ set. Not to be missed.
Supplier: www.clearaudio.de

  sleeve image
Recording=9, Music=10180g (Double) VinylSupplied by Clearaudio.de
       
 

John Abercrombie & Eddie Gomez with Gene Jackson - Structures
Chesky SACD317
Reviewed by DD
Arthur Fiedler and the Boston Pops were very popular half a century ago. They recorded some wonderful encore orchestral pieces and of course the (in)famous early Living Stereo of Offenbach’s Gaite Parisienne. This, in the right pressing has always been regarded as a sonic spectacular. However, whether or not the music is your cup of tea is another matter entirely. I’d always dismissed Fiedler as a serious conductor. The man was a great talent but because I’m so familiar with his ‘wallpaper’ recordings, having him record say a Beethoven symphony would be quite a shock to me. I don’t have, and didn’t want, an original of this recording so have nothing to compare and my feelings about this issue are mixed.
I find the sound quality excellent. If only all Living Stereo re-issues were given this treatment! But I find Suite No. 1 frankly boring. Suite No. 2 is much more interesting. The second side finishes with quite a lovely Lyric Suite which is comprised of four movements: Shepherd Boy, Norwegian Rustic March, Nocturne, March of the Dwarfs. You’ll have to decide if the performances are for you, but I can assure you that you won’t be disappointed in the sound quality.

  sleeve image
Recording=8, Music=8Hybrid SACD format
       
 

Karrin Allyson - Footprints
Pure Audiophile Records PA-014 (2)
Reviewed by DDD
I approach new releases by jazz vocalists with caution, but this one took me by surprise. I’ve enjoyed Allyson’s prior releases for Concord, but she’s finally put it all together in a package of songs that had me riveted from start to finish.
The concept here was to take jazz instrumental compositions, add lyrics by songwriter Chris Caswell, and round off the mix with tasteful accompaniment by Frank Wess on tenor saxophone, Bruce Barth on keyboards, Peter Washington on bass, Nick Philips on trumpet and Todd Strait on drums. Jon Hendricks adds vocals on three songs, and Karrin leaves little doubt that she could have stepped in for Annie Ross without disappointing Lambert, Hendricks & Ross fans. Karrin also gives us a tribute to the great Oscar Brown, Jr., performing his ‘A Tree And Me’ and ‘But I Was Cool’. Allyson handles this material without going over the hipster jive top (those familiar with Oscar Brown’s great album ‘Sin and Soul’ will know what I mean).
The original CD recording was mastered by George Horn at Fantasy Studios and sounded excellent. This new two LP re-issue has taken things up several notches. Stan Ricker did his half-speed mastering magic, adding two bonus tracks, with the 15 songs spread across two 180g LPs. The sound is spectacular.

  sleeve image
Recording=10, Music=8180g (Double) Vinyl
       
 

Clark Terry - Color Changes
Candid/ Pure Pleasure CJS 9009
Reviewed by DD
Despite a career stretching over 60 years, this 1960 release is widely recognised as Clark Terry’s best. It’s not difficult to see why, since he’s joined here by a stellar group including Yusef Lateef (tenor, flute, English horn, oboe, etc. etc.), Jimmy Knepper (trombone), Tommy Flanagan (piano), Joe Benjamin (bass), Seldon Powell (tenor, flute), Julius Watkins (French horn), and Ed Shaughnessy (drums). The opening ‘Blue Waltz’ immediately sets the pace with great solos from all, underpinned by deft and inventive percussion from Shaughnessy. Lateef’s ‘Brother Terry’ opens with a deep growl from Terry’s horn that immediately sets the tone for this evocative piece, further developed by sinuous lines from Lateef’s oboe. ‘Flutin’ and Fluglin’ does just what it says on the packet; light as air with the flutes of Powell and Lateef interacting superbly with Terry’s flugelhorn. ‘La Rive Gauche’ opens side 2 and is Terry’s tribute to “my favourite section of my favourite city”. My favourite number here ‘Nahstye (sic) Blues’ is the funkiest of the set and features a superb tenor solo from Lateef, some storming work from Terry and particularly inventive and powerful percussion from Shaughnessy. Well recorded, boasting an excellent pressing from Pallas and with not an ounce of fat in any of its seven numbers, this is a very welcome re-issue.

  sleeve image
Recording=8, Music=9180g Vinyl
       
 

The Tony Bennett Bill Evans Album
Analogue Productions 45 RPM limited edition
Reviewed by DDD
Bill Evans teamed up with Tony Bennett in June1975 to record this magic collaboration. Bennett, pushing 50 at the time, sang beautifully, but with was hardly at the peak of his powers. Compared to earlier recordings his voice had thickened and lost some elasticity. Evans, whose trio recordings ensured his place among the great jazz pianists, was slumming it playing what was a cabaret gig. Nonetheless, the pairing worked remarkably well, with Evans reading Bennett’s every mood as though he worked as an accompanist for a living. Original pressings of this Fantasy title rarely show up, and it’s hard to believe this record sold so few copies. Still, every copy of the original issue I have ever found had defective or disappointing sound. The record seemed to catch the fancy of record collectors when Mobile Fidelity Sound Labs released it heavy vinyl version. That sold out and itself went on to become a sought after collector’s item. That MoFi release was one of their best mastering jobs, and compares well with this re-issue. This one squeezes a bit more “you are there” out of the piano sound, but in a few places I hear what might be tape overload or damage in the vocals. This minor quibble aside, it’s an excellent job. Buy it now or wait until it sells out and pay double on eBay a year from now.

  sleeve image
Recording=9, Music=845 rpm vinyl multi disc
       
 

Lee Konitz - Motion
Speakers Corner/Verve
Reviewed by DDD
Alto saxophone extraordinaire Lee Konitz teamed up with Elvin Jones and Sonny Dallas for Motion, one of his finest albums. Konitz’s cool sound is played off against Jones’ usual frenetic pace to deliver an album that is riveting, adventurous and yet accessible. The Penguin Guide awarded this album one of its “crowns” designating a subjective favorite of the authors. Kontiz recorded prolifically throughout the last half of the twentieth century, and has continued to record and perform at a very high level. This 1961 record is certainly one of his best and a good place to start an exploration of this great altoist, who did more than simply follow in the footsteps of Charlie Parker, developing his own vocabulary. Now if we could only get a reissue of Lee Konitz with Warne Marsh on Atlantic, and then the rest of the Konitz Verves… Original copies of Motion are fairly scarce despite their relative youth, and Verve wasn’t always producing top quality pressing in the 1960s. The new Speakers Corner mastering sounds splendid and handily beats the original Verve stereo pressings, with the harmonic correctness immediately obvious. The stereo spread is not ideal, but my mono original falls short of the re-issue in every other respect.
This is one of the biggest sonic re-issue success stories I’ve heard – Speakers Corner turned an indifferently mastered original into a sonic gem.

  sleeve image
Recording=8, Music=10180g Vinyl
       
 

John Heard & Co. - The Jazz Composer’s Songbook
Straightahead-103
Reviewed by AKB
Welcome to the Fifties, where the finest Jazz music and Jazz recordings took place! Straightahead Records wants to recreate the era: just imagine a great live session at Bernie’s in Hollywood, pure analogue, recorded direct to two track, with titles from Horace Silver, Monk and Co. Those are the ingredients of The Jazz Composer’s Songbook. Heard, who used to play with Oscar Peterson and Count Basie, is just one part of a fantastic band. Danny Grissett, piano, Lorca Hart, drums, Herman Riley, tenor sax, and Nolan Shadeed, trumpet, prove that today you can still play in the spirit of Horace Silver, but with some modern flair too. ‘Soulville’ with an amazing unisono intro by sax and trumpet or ‘Doodlin’’ where Heard manages to apply Silver’s lively piano technique on his bass, ‘Valse Hot’ with its tricky rhythm brushed the wrong way: How many examples do you need to be convinced? My favourite song is ‘Dat Dere’ from Bobby Timmons: The beat goes straight into your feet, the five are swinging, it is just “straight ahead” jazz!
Without a doubt Straightahead Records, established by mastering legend Bernie Grundman and producer Stewart Levine, is set to become one of the finest jazz labels worldwide!

  sleeve image
Recording=10, Music=10200g VinylHybrid SACD Multichannel format
       
 

Sarah Vaughan In Hi-Fi - Pure Pleasure
Reviewed by DDD
One can walk into almost any used record store and find a selection of Sarah Vaughan recordings on Mercury, Roulette and Pablo. Two of my favorites pair Sassy with great trumpet players – Sarah Vaughan on EmArcy (with Clifford Brown) and this new release with Miles Davis. This fabulous record was recorded during several sessions between late 1949 and early 1952. The original album (Columbia CL 745) included eight numbers recorded in May 1950 with top-flight musicians, including Miles on trumpet and either Mundell Lowe or Freddie Green on guitar. Vaughan’s throaty, sexy voice is always the star of the show, whether backed by a nameless orchestra or jazz immortals. Everything on this album is top drawer, but some of the songs and pairings stay with you long after the music has subsided. Especially haunting are ‘Come Rain Or Come Shine’ with Mundell Lowe’s guitar accompaniment in the background, ‘Mean To Me’ with Budd Johnson on tenor sax and a very muted Miles in the background, and ‘It Might As Well Be Spring’ with Miles doubling Vaughan’s voice a half beat behind. Pure Pleasure has released this album with nine tracks not on the original LP spread out over two discs. Where the original LP had quite good sound on most tracks, merely serviceable sound on a few, Pure Pleasure has done an excellent job on the original mono tapes.

  sleeve image
Recording=8, Music=10180g Vinyl
       
  Top | Last page | Music Review Index | Technical Review Index | Back Issues Index | Show Reviews | Subscribe | Latest Issue | News | Letters
| Home page | Site Map |
 
  Music Reviews by Issue | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 | 32 | 33 | 34 | 35 | 36 | 37 | 38 | 39 | 40 | 41 | 42 | 43 | 44 | 45 | 46 | 47 | 48 | 49 | 50 | 51 | 52 | 53 | 54 | 55 | 56 | 57 | 58 | 59 | 60 |